Most dangerous time since the Cuban Missile Crisis: Dr Marianne Hanson on the nuclear talks
On the eve of the meeting between the leaders of the United States, Russia and China, ICAN Australia board member Dr Marianne Hanson, Honorary Associate Professor of International Relations at the University of Queensland, spoke with ABC’s Laura Tchilinguiriann about whether the talks could deliver, and why the risk of nuclear war is now higher than at any time since the Cuban Missile Crisis.
*Note: This interview was recorded before the summit. The talks ended without any specific agreement on nuclear arms control.
Most dangerous time since the Cuban Missile Crisis: Dr Marianne Hanson on the nuclear threat
Why the talks mattered
Laura Tchilinguiriann: Tomorrow’s unprecedented sit-down meeting between the world’s top three nuclear powers presents a unique opportunity. The nuclear arms control treaty between the US and Russia expired in February, leaving the world’s biggest nuclear arsenals without major guardrails and effectively ending the arms control cooperation that helped resolve the Cold War. The United Nations has urged both sides to agree on a new framework without delay. President Trump says he believes he can replace the deal with a better agreement, one that includes China, which has previously been closed to denuclearisation talks as it builds up its arsenal. On the surface, this meeting seems significant, but will we see any real change?
Dr Marianne Hanson: It’s hard to tell, Laura. First of all, I think it’s really important that this meeting is going ahead. It is imperative that leaders of major states sit down together, talk about these issues and, with luck, come up with some new treaties or agreements.
I know a lot of people are pooh-poohing it and saying it’s all just theatre, that Trump wants something that paints him in a rosy light, and the same for Putin. That may be the case. But for the past few years, so many arms control agreements have been killed off, these leaders have not been talking to each other, and we have not seen any progress towards making the world safer from nuclear war. So this is pretty important, and I think we ought to be supporting it.
Will it actually result in anything concrete? Possibly not overnight, but it is a good start.
Who needs to be at the table
Laura Tchilinguiriann: Should any other world leaders be in the room?
Dr Marianne Hanson: For the moment, these are the three most important leaders who need to be talking. They have the largest nuclear arsenals. The US and Russia have just over 5,000 nuclear weapons each. China has around 600, and that number is growing.
China’s position has been that it doesn’t want to talk about nuclear elimination. I think elimination is actually a better word than denuclearisation, because all of these states have committed to bringing their arsenals down to zero eventually. That is what we want to see: all nine nuclear-armed states moving towards zero nuclear weapons. So these three are the most important.
What does “denuclearisation” really mean?
Laura Tchilinguiriann: Donald Trump says the talks will cover denuclearisation, but what does that actually mean? Is it about reducing stockpiles, or what they can deploy, or is it, as you said, a full process of nuclear elimination? Do you think we could ever see that happen?
Dr Marianne Hanson: First of all, I think we could see that happen, and I think we absolutely need to see it happen. Many analysts and world leaders agree. We have 101 states that have already joined the United Nations Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons. Elimination is certainly doable over time, but it requires a tremendous amount of political will.
As for what denuclearisation means, we don’t actually know what Trump is talking about. He could simply be trying to gather support for preventing Iran from ever developing a nuclear weapon. Iran has no nuclear weapons, and it is a long way off from developing them. On the other hand, he could be sincerely talking about resurrecting some kind of arms control treaty with Russia, because those have all now expired and been cast away. Or he may want to bring China into the picture and talk about all three states gradually reducing their stockpiles, which are obscenely high.
We won’t know until the talks actually happen whether he is simply talking about other states, “rogue states” as he would say, being denied nuclear weapons, or whether he is serious, as he should be, about all nine nuclear-armed states eventually moving to zero. In other words, can this double standard really be upheld? There is a lot of hypocrisy in what these nine states are saying and doing.
The most dangerous time since the Cuban Missile Crisis
Laura Tchilinguirian: Marianne, how would you describe the current global nuclear threat? How does it compare to five or even ten years ago?
Dr Marianne Hanson: Unfortunately, it is very high, and most people aren’t really aware of this danger. We now have absolutely no arms control agreements or guardrails between the two major superpowers. The last one expired in February. That means that, unlike in previous decades, these states are technically able to deploy, to test and to expand their arsenals. That is a very bad thing, and we need to get guardrails back in place.
Second, all of these states have at one point or another talked about actually using their nuclear weapons. And there is always the danger of inadvertent use or escalation. Many people are saying this is the most dangerous time for nuclear war since the Cuban Missile Crisis. In other words, it is worse than in the 1970s and 1980s.
Three flashpoints
Laura Tchilinguirian: Where is the strongest risk coming from?
Dr Marianne Hanson: I think the risks are most likely to be between Russia and NATO, unless that war is resolved and serious negotiations are put in place. This is far too important an issue to be fiddling around with. We need an end to this war, we need negotiations, and we need new arms control agreements, because Putin, Trump and previous American leaders have all talked about the use of nuclear weapons. This has to stop.
The other flashpoint could well be India and Pakistan, which has typically been a very volatile part of the world for nuclear threats and missiles.
And then, of course, there is the situation between the US, Israel and Iran. Israel has around 100 nuclear weapons, and the Samson Option talks about the potential use of nuclear weapons against any country.
So there are at least three key flashpoints. We have to wind down this rhetoric and make serious moves to rein these countries in and hold them to the promise of nuclear elimination.